Kriyā, Caryā, Yoga and Jñāna: from the parts of a Tantra to the nine vehicles

Long before they named rungs on a ladder, kriyā, caryā, yoga and jñāna named the four dimensions of a single revelation. A Tantra, as the Indian masters of the Śaiva Āgamas and the Pāñcarātra conceived it, was a whole world of the sacred: the sacred act of ritual, the sacred life of conduct, the sacred interiority of yoga, and the liberating knowledge that gives all of these their meaning. These four were the quarters (pādas) of one body of teaching, as the four directions belong to one horizon.

The centuries that followed took these same words and set them one above the other. In the Tamil Śaiva saints they became four stages in the approach of the bound self to Śiva, from servant to son, from son to friend, from friend to union. In Kashmir the tension between ritual and knowledge grew into a hierarchy of whole revelations, crowned by the knowledge that needs no means at all. And in the Secret Mantra of the Buddhists they became the names of classes of scripture, kriyā tantra, caryā or ubhaya tantra and yoga tantra, each a vehicle in its own right, each surpassed by the great yogas that came after.

Atiyoga has its own hidden history within this movement. Before it was a vehicle it was a moment. In Indian Tantras of the eighth century, yoga, anuyoga, atiyoga and mahāyoga name successive phases of one practice, and atiyoga is the phase in which the true nature is directly known. The earliest Tibetan masters of the ancient tradition still speak of Mahāyoga, Anuyoga and Atiyoga as three modes of a single path: generation, completion and the Great Perfection that is their consummation. Only in the eleventh century does Atiyoga stand clearly as the ninth and highest vehicle, the summit where all paths come to rest; and even then a great Sakya master could say that its view is wisdom itself, and no vehicle at all.

The intuition that the nine vehicles preserve, in a new arrangement, an older vision in which every Tantra embraced ritual, conduct, yoga and knowledge is therefore profoundly right, with two refinements. The Buddhist classes did not simply descend from the Śaiva pādas: both appear in the same century, drawing on a vocabulary that Indian religion held in common. And the place that Atiyoga came to occupy was not first the knowledge-quarter of a scripture but the culminating moment of a sādhana, the instant in which the whole practice opens into what it was always pointing towards. The path of these words leads from the Indian scriptures to the living Nyingma understanding of today.

The four quarters of an Indian Tantra

In the Śaiva Siddhānta, the great tradition of Śaiva initiation and temple worship, a complete scripture was understood to have four quarters. The vidyāpāda or jñānapāda reveals what is to be known: the Lord (pati), the bound selves (paśu) and the bonds (pāśa) that hold them, the levels of reality (tattva) through which consciousness descends and returns, and the nature of liberation. The kriyāpāda gives the sacred acts: initiation (dīkṣā), daily worship, the building and consecration of temples and images, the great festivals of the year. The yogapāda opens the inner way of breath, subtle body and meditative ascent through the tattvas. The caryāpāda shapes the life of the initiate: the observances, the disciplines of purity, the rules of conduct and the means of repairing what has been broken.

The Mṛgendra Āgama is built in exactly these four quarters, as vidyā, kriyā, caryā and yoga, and the Mataṅgapārameśvara follows the same plan as vidyā, kriyā, yoga and caryā. The later masters of the Siddhānta took this shape as the very form of revelation and spoke of each of the twenty-eight Siddhānta Āgamas as possessing its four quarters, whether or not the manuscripts have preserved them.

The ideal is younger than it appears. The oldest surviving Śaiva scripture, the Niśvāsa corpus, knows nothing of this division, and among the many Āgamas the fourfold form is the exception rather than the rule. It belongs to the more learned and systematic works, roughly from the eighth century onwards, composed by masters who wished a single revelation to hold doctrine, ritual, meditation and the rule of life in one luminous order. Most of the southern Āgamas that survive in full are in truth kriyā and caryā: the scriptures of the temple and its priesthood, in which the knowledge-quarter is brief or has fallen away.

The Pāñcarātra tells the same story. Among the printed Saṃhitās only the Pādma Saṃhitā is divided into the four, in the order jñāna, yoga, kriyā, caryā, and its proportions speak eloquently. The jñānapāda, on God, creation, the individual selves, bondage, liberation and the cosmos, has twelve chapters; the yogapāda, on the eight limbs and the subtle body, has five. The kriyāpāda, on the building of temples, the consecration of images and the forms of the deities, has thirty-two; the caryāpāda, on conduct, initiation, daily worship, the five daily duties, vows, expiation, mudrā and mantra, has thirty-three. The older and more venerable Saṃhitās, the Jayākhya, the Sātvata and the Pauṣkara, and the Lakṣmī Tantra as well, are not divided in this way at all.

At the threshold of its kriyāpāda the Pādma Saṃhitā says for whom each quarter is meant. Those rich in understanding reach liberation through knowledge and yoga; those without such learning are carried by the worship of the temple. The four quarters are therefore more than topics. In the very scripture that names them, knowledge and yoga are already the way of the few, ritual and conduct the way of the many. In that quiet ranking lies the seed of everything that was to follow.

What the four words meant

Kriyā comes from the root kṛ, to do, and in the tantric world it means the act that is done according to revelation: the rite. It is the drawing of the maṇḍala, the purification of the elements, the installation of mantras on the body, the offering into fire, the initiation that cuts the bonds. It is never a merely outward performance. In the Śaiva understanding kriyā is one of the three powers of the Lord himself, together with will (icchā) and knowledge (jñāna). When the ācārya performs the rite, it is Śiva's own power of action that moves through his hands.

This is why, in the Śaiva Siddhānta, kriyā was not the lower path but the liberating one. Its great masters, Sadyojyoti and Rāmakaṇṭha among them, taught that the impurity (mala) which binds the self is a real substance, and that a substance is not dissolved by understanding, as darkness in a room is not dispelled by knowing that a lamp exists. Only an act of the Lord's power can remove it, and that act is initiation. Knowledge illumines the path; the rite opens it.

Caryā comes from the root car, to move, to walk, to live, and means the way one walks through the world: conduct, observance, the disciplined form of a life. It is the vrata of the initiate, the daily rule, the purity of body and food, the vow kept through every hour. In some Śaiva circles caryā took startling forms, the ascetic's deliberate courting of contempt, the cremation-ground observance of the Kapālika. In every form it means that the teaching is lived in the body of one's days, not only performed in the shrine.

Yoga, from the root yuj, to yoke and to join, is the inner discipline: the stilling and gathering of the mind, the mastery of breath, the ascent along the central channel, the meditative union with the deity and with the levels of reality. In the Āgamas it is a ladder of absorption (dhāraṇā) through the tattvas, by which the yogin comes to know and command each plane of existence.

Jñāna or vidyā, from the roots jñā and vid, to know and to see, is the knowledge that illumines all the rest. In the scriptures it is first of all doctrine, the revealed account of the deity, the self, bondage and freedom. Yet the word always carried more than doctrine. It also meant the knowledge in which the self recognises its own nature, the omniscience (sarvajñatva) and sovereign agency (sarvakartṛtva) that the liberated self shares with Śiva. The doctrinal chapter and that living knowledge share one name, and the whole later history of these terms turns on the movement from the one to the other.

Read together, the four quarters describe a complete life in the sacred: how to act, how to live, how to turn inward, and what is ultimately the case. Each is a dimension of one revelation, and each presupposes the others. The priest who performs the rite must keep the observances; the yogin who ascends the tattvas must know what they are; the knower who recognises his nature still bows before the image at dawn.

From quarters to stages

The tendency to rank action below knowledge is far older than the Tantras. The Bhagavad Gītā already weighs the path of works against the path of knowledge, and Patañjali opens the second book of the Yoga Sūtra with kriyāyoga, the yoga of action, made of austerity (tapas), sacred study (svādhyāya) and surrender to the Lord (īśvarapraṇidhāna). It is offered to those not yet ready for the effortless absorption taught in the first book: a yoga of preparation, which thins the afflictions and makes samādhi possible. Here, centuries before the Āgamas, kriyā already names the outer, purifying work that precedes the inner.

It was in the Tamil country that the four quarters of the Āgamas became, in the fullest sense, four stages of a single journey. Tirumūlar's Tirumantiram and the Śivañānasiddhiyār of Aruṇandi teach them as successive paths, each with its own relation to the Lord and its own fruit. In caryā, called the way of the servant (dāsamārga), the devotee serves Śiva's temple with his hands: he sweeps its courts, gathers flowers, weaves garlands, lights the lamps; and his fruit is to dwell in Śiva's world (sālokya). In kriyā, the way of the good son (satputramārga), he worships Śiva in the image and in the fire with the full rite, and his fruit is to dwell near the Lord (sāmīpya). In yoga, the way of the friend (sakhamārga), he seeks Śiva within through meditation and attains a form like Śiva's own (sārūpya). In jñāna, the true way (sanmārga), he knows Śiva in his own being and attains union (sāyujya), which alone is final.

Two things in this transformation deserve attention. The first is that the order has changed: caryā now stands at the bottom and kriyā above it, because the humble service of the temple comes before the right to perform its rites. The second is that each stage is defined by a relationship: servant, son, friend, one with the Lord. The ladder of practice has become a ladder of intimacy, in which the distance between worshipper and worshipped narrows until nothing remains of it. This same pattern, servant before master, friend beside friend, and finally no two at all, will reappear with remarkable faithfulness in the Buddhist classification of the Tantras.

The Pāñcarātra did not take this step as fully, but the Pādma Saṃhitā had already pointed the way when it reserved knowledge and yoga for the learned and gave the temple to everyone else. Once the quarters are matched to kinds of people, they have become rungs. From then on, to speak of kriyā is to speak not only of a subject but of a level.

Kashmir: knowledge as the liberating act

In Kashmir the question of kriyā and jñāna became the axis of a great debate. Against the Siddhānta conviction that the rite of initiation alone removes the substance of impurity, Abhinavagupta set out, in the first chapter of the Tantrāloka, a deeper analysis. There are two kinds of ignorance, he teaches: an ignorance rooted in the person (pauruṣa ajñāna), which initiation removes, and an ignorance of the intellect (bauddha ajñāna), which only knowledge removes. Initiation is not set aside. But it is understood as the Lord's own self-revelation, and liberation is complete only when the initiate knows what he is. Knowledge is no longer a chapter of doctrine; it is the liberating event itself.

From the Mālinīvijayottara Tantra Abhinavagupta received three modes of immersion (samāveśa) in the divine: the Śāmbhava, in which consciousness rests in Śiva without any thought; the Śākta, in which a purified insight is cultivated; and the Āṇava, which works through breath, body, mantra, meditation and the outer supports of practice, ritual among them. To these he added a fourth, the means beyond all means (anupāya), in which the disciple recognises his own nature on hearing a single word from the master, and nothing further remains to be done. The Tantrāloka unfolds them from the summit downwards: the means-less in its second chapter, then Śāmbhava, Śākta and Āṇava in the third, fourth and fifth. Kriyā has found its place within the āṇava means, the most outward of the ways, while the summit is pure, effortless recognition.

Abhinavagupta also ranked the whole range of revelations known to him. The Veda stands below the Siddhānta; the Siddhānta below the Vāma and Dakṣiṇa scriptures; these below the Mata, the Kula and the Kaula; and the Trika, which he held to embrace them all, at the top. Each higher revelation includes the lower and reveals its true meaning. Here, in Kashmir, in the tenth and eleventh centuries, is a full hierarchy of scriptural classes crowned by a teaching of effortless recognition. The kinship with the Nyingma ordering of the vehicles, crowned by Atiyoga, is unmistakable, even though neither tradition borrowed it from the other.

Yet the Tantrāloka itself preserves the older wholeness. It is built as a complete Tantra in the ancient sense: its first chapters set out knowledge and the means of realisation, and from the thirteenth chapter onwards, beginning with the descent of grace (śaktipāta), it unfolds initiation, worship and the whole ritual life of the tradition. Ritual is not abandoned at the summit. It is reread as the spontaneous expression of a realisation already present, the play of the very consciousness that knowledge has recognised.

The Buddhist Tantras: from quarters to classes

The Buddhist Secret Mantra grew from a long literature of ritual: the dhāraṇī scriptures, the ritual manuals called kalpa, of which the Mañjuśrīmūlakalpa is the greatest, and works such as the Susiddhikara, the Subāhuparipṛcchā and the Dhyānottara. Their world is the world of the kriyāpāda: the choice of a pure place, bathing and fresh garments, offerings, fire rites, the measured recitation of mantra, and the deity approached with reverence as a lord who grants accomplishment.

In the eighth century Indian masters began to classify this growing body of scripture, and they did so with the old words. Buddhaguhya, the great commentator of the Mahāvairocanābhisambodhi, the Dhyānottara and the Subāhu, distinguished kriyā Tantras and yoga Tantras, and placed the Mahāvairocana between them as a Tantra of both (ubhaya), since it joins the outer conduct of kriyā to the inner meditation of yoga. Vilāsavajra, a little later in the same century, names the three as kriyā, caryā and yoga. Caryā and ubhaya are thus two names for one class: the first says what it teaches, the conduct of the practitioner; the second says where it stands, embracing both sides. The Tibetan Nyingma tradition still calls it the Upa Tantra, after ubhaya.

With this a decisive change has taken place. A word that in the Śaiva scriptures named a part of every Tantra now names a kind of Tantra. Yet the change is less abrupt than it seems. The Buddhist masters looked at each scripture and asked which of the old dimensions governs it. A scripture in which rite and purity predominate is a kriyā Tantra. One in which outer conduct and inner meditation stand in balance is an ubhaya Tantra. One in which the inner union with the deity governs all, as in the Sarvatathāgatatattvasaṃgraha, is a yoga Tantra. The class-name is still the name of a quarter; it now characterises the whole by its ruling part.

As further revelations appeared they were placed above the three. The Guhyasamāja and its family became the great yoga (mahāyoga) or the higher yoga (yogottara); the Hevajra, the Cakrasaṃvara and the Tantras of the yoginīs became the unsurpassed yoga (yoganiruttara), which Tibetan translators rendered as yoga beyond which there is none. The later Tibetan schools fixed the scheme as four: kriyā, caryā, yoga and anuttarayoga. The ancient school kept the older Indian division, three outer Tantras, kriyā, ubhaya and yoga, below three inner yogas, mahā, anu and ati.

The masters of the Nyingma describe the outer three in a way that would have been immediately familiar to Tirumūlar. In kriyā the deity is regarded as a lord and oneself as a servant; purity is kept by bathing, by changing one's garments and by the three white foods, and accomplishment is received as a gift. In ubhaya the view is that of yoga and the conduct that of kriyā, and the deity is regarded as a friend, an equal. In yoga oneself and the deity are inseparable, and outer purity is kept only as a support. Servant, friend, and finally no two at all: the same ladder of intimacy that the Tamil saints had found in the quarters of the Āgama. A celebrated image in the explanatory Tantras, repeated by the Tibetan masters, says the same through the language of desire: the four classes take the bliss of the path as lovers do by laughing, by gazing, by holding hands and by union.

One point of chronology must be held firmly. The Buddhist three-class scheme and the Śaiva ideal of four quarters both appear in the eighth century. The Buddhist classes cannot simply be derived from the Śaiva quarters. Both traditions drew on a vocabulary that Indian religion held in common, in which kriyā meant the rite, caryā the observance, yoga the inner discipline and jñāna the knowledge that liberates; and both, independently, turned that vocabulary into a ladder.

Caryā as the conduct of realisation

While caryā became the name of a modest class of scripture, the word lived on in the higher Tantras with a far more radiant meaning. In the Hevajra, the Cakrasaṃvara and the other Tantras of the yoginīs, caryā is the conduct of the yogin who has ripened in practice and now carries realisation into the open world. He wanders among the sacred sites and the cremation grounds, joins the feasts of the yoginīs, and keeps the observance of the madman (unmattavrata), testing whether his realisation holds when every convention falls away. The Hevajra Tantra devotes a chapter to this conduct, and the later commentators teach it as the stage that follows accomplishment in meditation, not as a preliminary to it.

The siddhas of eastern India sang of this conduct. Their songs, gathered as the Caryāgītikoṣa, the Treasury of Songs of Conduct, were composed in the old vernacular of Bengal and sung at the gatherings of the yogins. Among their authors are Lūyipā, Kāṇhapā, Bhusukupā and Sarahapāda, the same Saraha whose dohās became one of the great sources of the Mahāmudrā. In these songs caryā is no longer an observance laid upon the practitioner from outside. It is the natural movement of a mind that has recognised its nature, playful, unbound and spontaneous.

This meaning has deep Indian roots on the Śaiva side as well, in the great observance (mahāvrata) of the Kapālikas and the provocative observance of the Pāśupatas, both of which made conduct itself a method of liberation. And it survives at the heart of the Nyingma: every vehicle is taught under view, meditation, conduct and fruit, and in Mahāyoga conduct is divided into the elaborate, the unelaborate and the utterly unelaborate. In Atiyoga conduct is freedom from hope and fear, from accepting and rejecting. Caryā, which began as the rule of the initiate's day, ends as the unforced action of rigpa itself.

Atiyoga before it was a vehicle

The word atiyoga first appears not as the name of a vehicle but as the name of a moment. In the Sarvabuddhasamāyoga, a Tantra of the eighth century and one of the earliest of the yoginī scriptures, practice unfolds through yoga, anuyoga and atiyoga. Anuyoga is the stage of yogic bliss; and of atiyoga the Tantra says that through it the true nature is fully experienced. The verse survives in Sanskrit because Āryadeva quotes it in the ninth chapter of his Caryāmelāpakapradīpa, the Lamp that Integrates the Practices. In the Kṛṣṇayamāri Tantra the same words return as four stages of one sādhana, yoga, anuyoga, atiyoga and mahāyoga, with atiyoga standing just before the last.

The Guhyagarbha, the root Tantra of the Nyingma Mahāyoga, gives the moment its lasting name. After the creation of the deity and the maṇḍala, and after their completion and dissolution into oneself, it speaks of rdzogs pa chen po, the Great Perfection, in which one rests in the naturally luminous and pure mind. Here the Great Perfection is not a separate system. It is the consummation of deity yoga, the point at which everything that has been generated and completed is recognised as never having been other than the nature of mind.

The earliest Tibetan writings preserve this understanding. A short work attributed to Padmasambhava teaches deity yoga in three phases: generation (bskyed), completion (rdzogs) and Great Perfection (rdzogs chen). The Garland of Views, ascribed to the same master and composed as an instruction on the thirteenth chapter of the Guhyagarbha, divides the inner yoga into the way of generation, the way of completion and the way of the Great Perfection, three modes of one inner yoga. Among the manuscripts found at Dunhuang, the Questions and Answers on Vajrasattva presents a passage on deity yoga that an early reader marked as an explanation of the view of Atiyoga, and its words are simple: in the ultimate deity yoga no subject and no object is perceived.

Here the intuition about the knowledge-quarter finds its most precise confirmation. In a single sādhana the old dimensions of a Tantra are all present in miniature: the ritual act of arranging and invoking (kriyā), the disciplined form of the practice (caryā), the yogic generation and completion (yoga), and at the end the recognition of the nature in which the whole display arises and dissolves (jñāna). Atiyoga was the name of that last moment. It was the jñāna of the practice, the place where method opens into wisdom.

The nine vehicles take shape in Tibet

The manuscripts sealed in the cave at Dunhuang allow us to watch the nine vehicles being born. One of them, the Seven Great Transmissions, sets out seven kinds of teaching, the śrāvakas, the non-tantric Mahāyāna, kriyā, yoga, mahāyoga, anuyoga and atiyoga, and describes each under view, meditation, conduct and vows. Another already contains all nine classes in their later order, distinguished by the deities they practise, the relationship between deity and practitioner, and the signs of accomplishment; yet it never once calls them vehicles. In texts of the tenth century Mahāyoga, Anuyoga and Atiyoga are named separately, but Anuyoga and Atiyoga are still described as modes of Mahāyoga practice, without a body of teaching of their own.

Nubchen Sangye Yeshe, the great master of the ninth and early tenth centuries, stands at the turning point. In the Armour against Darkness, his commentary on the Gongpa Düpa, the root scripture of Anuyoga, Mahā, Anu and Ati are the lower, middle and higher divisions of a single vehicle. In the Lamp for the Eye of Contemplation (Samten Migdrön) he sets four approaches side by side: the gradual path of the Indian Mahāyāna, the sudden path of the Chinese masters, Mahāyoga and Atiyoga, with Atiyoga at the summit. Sometimes he calls it a vehicle, sometimes a view. The moment is becoming a way.

By the eleventh century the transformation is complete. Rongzom Chökyi Zangpo defends the Great Perfection as the culmination of the Buddha's teaching, and the nine vehicles stand in their classical form. The Tantras of the Great Perfection now speak of themselves in these terms: the Tantra of the Luminous Expanse calls itself the peak of the nine vehicles. Not everyone accepted this. In the thirteenth century Sakya Paṇḍita wrote in his Clear Differentiation of the Three Vows that the view of Atiyoga is wisdom and not a vehicle, unknowingly echoing the very understanding from which Atiyoga had grown.

The Omniscient Longchenpa gave the nine vehicles their lasting architecture in the Treasury of Philosophical Tenets and the Treasury of the Supreme Vehicle. He gathered them into three triads. The vehicles that lead away from the origin of suffering are those of the śrāvakas, the pratyekabuddhas and the bodhisattvas. The vehicles of Vedic austerity (dka' thub rig byed) are kriyā, ubhaya and yoga. The vehicles of overpowering means are mahāyoga, anuyoga and atiyoga. The name of the middle triad deserves to be read slowly. Dka' thub is the Tibetan for tapas, ascetic discipline, and rig byed is the Tibetan for the Veda. The Nyingma tradition itself recognised that the outer Tantras, with their bathing, their pure garments, their white foods and their reverent service of a deity above, belong to the same world of ritual purity as the Brahmanical rites and the kriyā and caryā quarters of the Āgamas.

Rigdzin Jigme Lingpa, in the Treasury of Precious Qualities, presents the nine vehicles as a single graded path along which beings of every capacity are led, and in his Longchen Nyingthig every sādhana still moves through generation and completion into the open rest of the Great Perfection. The vehicles have become separate, ranked and complete in themselves; and yet in the practice of every day they remain, as they were in the beginning, moments of one movement.

Atiyoga as it is understood today

In the living Nyingma tradition Atiyoga is the ninth and highest vehicle, the vehicle of the vajra essence. It has its own scriptures, the Tantras of the mind series, the space series and the instruction series, with the Seventeen Tantras at the heart of the last. It has its own path: the introduction to rigpa by the master, cutting through to primordial purity (trekchö) and the direct leap into spontaneous presence (thögal). Its view is the primordial wisdom that is the ground of all appearance, its meditation is resting in that wisdom without fabrication, its conduct is free of hope and fear, and its fruit is the recognition of the three kāyas as never having been apart from oneself.

Yet the great masters have always held two ways of seeing the nine vehicles together. In the first, they are a path of ascent, each vehicle preparing the way for the next, as Rigdzin Jigme Lingpa presents them in the Treasury of Precious Qualities. In the second, which the Omniscient Longchenpa unfolds in the Treasury of the Supreme Vehicle, Atiyoga is not only the highest vehicle but the nature that every vehicle is approaching, each according to the capacity of those who travel it. The lower vehicles are not wrong; they are partial views of what the Great Perfection sees whole. It is in this second sense that Atiyoga can be called the vehicle beyond vehicles, and that Sakya Paṇḍita's objection, that it is wisdom rather than a way, turns out to be, from within the tradition, its highest praise.

Much of the older wholeness also survives in the structure of the Tantras themselves. The Nyingma masters teach that every Tantra treats ten subjects: view, conduct, maṇḍala, empowerment, samaya, accomplishment, offering, enlightened activity, mudrā and mantra. Every vehicle is taught under view, meditation, conduct and fruit. These are the old quarters of the Indian scripture in a new arrangement: knowledge as view, yoga as meditation, caryā as conduct, and the whole world of kriyā in maṇḍala, empowerment, offering, mudrā and mantra.

And it survives above all in practice. Every Nyingma sādhana still moves through the three inner yogas within a single sitting: the deity and maṇḍala arise in generation, which is Mahāyoga; they are drawn into the subtle body and dissolved in completion, which is Anuyoga; and at the end the practitioner rests in the natural state, which is Atiyoga. The kriyā Tantras too are still practised as genres in their own right, with their purifications, fasts and recitations. Atiyoga as the summit of the nine vehicles and Atiyoga as the moment of recognition at the end of every practice are not two things. The second is the root from which the first grew.

What the history reveals

A master of the Śaiva Siddhānta would indeed have smiled at the idea that kriyā and caryā are kinds of scripture. For him they were quarters of every complete revelation: the rite and the rule of life, standing beside yoga and the liberating knowledge, each needing the others. The Dzogchen practitioner who meets these words first as the names of lower vehicles is meeting them late in their long life, after they had passed from parts to stages and from stages to classes.

The history refines this picture in three ways. The fourfold Tantra was an ideal of the learned more than the shape of the oldest scriptures, and already in the Pādma Saṃhitā its quarters were matched to different kinds of people and quietly ranked. The Buddhist classes arose in the same century as that ideal, so they are not its direct offspring; both grew from a vocabulary that the whole of tantric India shared. And when the Buddhist masters named a Tantra kriyā or ubhaya or yoga, they were naming it by the quarter that ruled it, so that the old meaning of the word lives on inside the new one.

On Atiyoga the intuition goes to the heart of the matter. Atiyoga did not begin as the knowledge-quarter of a scripture, but it began as something very close to it: the culminating moment of a single practice, in which the true nature is directly known. In the Sarvabuddhasamāyoga, in the Guhyagarbha and in the earliest Tibetan teachings, the Great Perfection is the jñāna of the sādhana, the point at which ritual, discipline and yoga open into wisdom. The nine vehicles took that moment and made it a summit, and they took the old parts of a Tantra and made them steps of a stair. Both readings are true. The stair is real, because beings ripen gradually. The single movement is real, because what is reached at the top is what was present at every step.

This is why the tradition can say, without contradiction, that Atiyoga is the highest of the nine vehicles and that it is no vehicle at all. Kriyā is the reverent act, caryā the life that carries it, yoga the turning inward, and jñāna the recognition that there was never anywhere to go. In India these were the four quarters of one revelation. In the Great Perfection they become, once more, the four faces of one realisation.

Next
Next

Rtog pa and Vikalpa: What “Conceptual” Really Means